« Smile! | Main | Dr. Mahathir »

October 23, 2003

Comments

Russell Arben Fox

Hey,

"The Quiet American," the film, was okay. Nice acting, nice photography. But I think it failed as drama for a much simpler reason than your admittedly on-target comments about allegory. Basically, Philip Noyce has no guilt. But Graham Greene had tons of it, and that lent a desperate tension to all his works, whether great or middling. Greene was acutely aware of the huge elephantine sin sitting in the room when his protagonists debate the fate of Thomas Fowler's Vietnamese mistress. Does she have anything to say for herself? Does she have dignity? Does she have rights? No! She's poor and backward and utterly dependent upon what various Westerners insist should become of her. Which is despicable, of course. Which is why Graham Greene's original vision of Vietnam, interestingly but ultimately poorly captured by Philip Noyce on screen, has great power. As much as he loathed Americans (and he did), Greene loathed his own people in equal measure, though in different ways. In Graham Greene's The Quiet American, everyone is a hopeless bastard; no one is clean. Whereas in the movie, Fowler's only real sin is that it takes him so long to "wake up" and "take sides." Note that in the end of film, Fowler tells his mistress, "I just wanted to tell someone I was sorry." Whereas in the book, Fowler concludes, "How I wish there was someone I could apologize to." In the former case, a man apologizes for the troublesome nature of his (otherwise justified) actions. Whereas in the latter, a man acknowledges that there is no one he can justify his (selfishly sinful, even if correct!) actions to.

Data

I too believe the book is better than the movie. The movie was less subtle in portraying Alden Pyle's guilt & Fowler's "heroism": the scenes where Brendan Fraser spouts fluent Vietnamese & collaborates with that general are shocking & conspiratorial indeed, but they didn't happen in the book. In the book it's not even all that clear that Pyle knew what he was doing with planning the bombing, not to mention whether what he was doing was wrong or not.

How much of a hero is Fowler anyway? Because he "took sides"? I'm just not sure that his move against Pyle's interference was all that courageous. We should bear in mind that he did have a strong personal motive for doing so.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Email John & Belle

  • he.jpgjholbo-at-mac-dot-com
  • she.jpgbbwaring-at-yahoo-dot-com

Google J&B


J&B Archives

Buy Reason and Persuasion!

S&O @ J&B

  • www.flickr.com
    This is a Flickr badge showing items in a set called Squid and Owl. Make your own badge here.

Reason and Persuasion Illustrations

  • www.flickr.com

J&B Have A Tipjar


  • Search Now:

  • Buy a couple books, we get a couple bucks.
Blog powered by Typepad

J&B Have A Comment Policy

  • This edited version of our comment policy is effective as of May 10, 2006.

    By publishing a comment to this blog you are granting its proprietors, John Holbo and Belle Waring, the right to republish that comment in any way shape or form they see fit.

    Severable from the above, and to the extent permitted by law, you hereby agree to the following as well: by leaving a comment you grant to the proprietors the right to release ALL your comments to this blog under this Creative Commons license (attribution 2.5). This license allows copying, derivative works, and commercial use.

    Severable from the above, and to the extent permitted by law, you are also granting to this blog's proprietors the right to so release any and all comments you may make to any OTHER blog at any time. This is retroactive. By publishing ANY comment to this blog, you thereby grant to the proprietors of this blog the right to release any of your comments (made to any blog, at any time, past, present or future) under the terms of the above CC license.

    Posting a comment constitutes consent to the following choice of law and choice of venue governing any disputes arising under this licensing arrangement: such disputes shall be adjudicated according to Canadian law and in the courts of Singapore.

    If you do NOT agree to these terms, for pete's sake do NOT leave a comment. It's that simple.

  • Confused by our comment policy?

    We're testing a strong CC license as a form of troll repellant. Does that sound strange? Read this thread. (I know, it's long. Keep scrolling. Further. Further. Ah, there.) So basically, we figure trolls will recognize that selling coffee cups and t-shirts is the best revenge, and will keep away. If we're wrong about that, at least someone can still sell the cups and shirts. (Sigh.)